.jpeg){kind=small}
Case Analysis Jafar Khaja Mainuddin Mulla vs State Of Maharashtra 2026 BHC-KOL 3759-DB
Synopsis
The appellant, convicted for murder under section 302 ipc and sentenced to life imprisonment, filed a criminal appeal. As his sentence neared completion (expected release on 1st july 2026), he sought to withdraw the appeal. The high court, relying on the supreme court’s decision in bani singh v. state of up, held that after an appeal is admitted, the court cannot dismiss it for non-prosecution or allow withdrawal without hearing on merits; it must dispose of the appeal on merits after perusing the record. Accordingly, the court appointed a legal aid counsel, heard the appeal on merits, and dismissed it, upholding the conviction. The court found that the chain of circumstantial evidence (last seen together, locked room, death by strangulation, no explanation from accused) was complete and proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Court: High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Circuit Bench at Kolhapur (Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Madhav J. Jamdar and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Pravin S. Patil (Division Bench)
Date of Judgment: 27th April 2026
Citation: 2026:BHC-KOL:3759-D (as appears in judgment)
Core Law: Criminal Law – Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Section 302 – murder); Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Sections 385, 386 – appeal procedure); Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (circumstantial evidence, extra‑judicial confession).
1. Heading of the judgment
High court of judicature at bombay circuit bench at kolhapur criminal appellate jurisdiction
Criminal appeal no. 1197 of 2022
Jafar khaja mainuddin mulla (appellant) vs. State of maharashtra (respondent)
Coram: hon’ble mr. justice madhav j. jamdar and hon’ble mr. justice pravin s. patil
Date: 27th april, 2026
2. Legal framework
Major laws and provisions involved:
Indian penal code, 1860 – section 302 (punishment for murder)
Code of criminal procedure, 1973 – sections 385 and 386 (procedure for appeal; mandatory disposal on merits after hearing or perusal of record)
Indian evidence act, 1872 – p
... Upgrade to a Premium Plan to view the full judgment.