top of page
Question Bank
Question
In the context of long-term Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), what is the legal significance of a "Change in Law" clause, and what is its intended purpose?
Solution
A "Change in Law" clause is a critical contractual provision in long-term Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) that allocates the risk associated with future changes in legislation or government policy. Its purpose is to protect the parties, typically the power generator, from the financial impact of any event that occurs after the bid submission date which makes performance more costly or onerous. The core objective is restitution, aiming to restore the affected party to the same economic position it would have been in had the change in law not occurred. This is often achieved through compensatory tariff adjustments, ensuring that the fundamental commercial bargain of the PPA is preserved despite unforeseen regulatory shifts.
Question
Describe the roles of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) and the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL) under the Electricity Act, 2003.
Solution
The Electricity Act, 2003 established a specialized regulatory framework for the power sector. The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) is an expert regulatory body with the authority to regulate tariffs for power generation and inter-state transmission, adjudicate disputes, and issue licenses. It functions as a quasi-judicial authority for matters within its jurisdiction. Appeals against the orders of the CERC lie with the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL), which is the specialized appellate body for resolving disputes in the electricity sector. The principle of judicial deference often applies to their decisions, meaning courts are slow to interfere unless the expert bodies' rulings are arbitrary, illegal, or violate statutory provisions.
Question
What is the process of tariff-based competitive bidding under Section 63 of the Electricity Act, 2003, and what is its primary objective?
Solution
Section 63 of the Electricity Act, 2003 provides a framework for procuring power through a tariff-based competitive bidding process. The primary objective of this process is to promote transparency, foster competition, and ultimately procure electricity at a competitive tariff for consumers. The Central Government notifies Standard Bidding Guidelines to govern this process. Prospective power generators submit their bids, and the contract is awarded to the bidder who meets the technical qualifications and offers the most competitive tariff. This process ensures that power procurement is cost-effective and avoids the need for regulators to determine tariffs on a cost-plus basis.
Question
Explain the "restitutionary principle" as applied to compensation for a 'Change in Law' event in commercial contracts.
Solution
The restitutionary principle in the context of a 'Change in Law' event is a foundational concept for calculating compensation. It is not intended to provide a windfall profit or punish either party. Instead, the sole purpose is to restore the affected party to the exact economic position it would have enjoyed if the change in law had never happened. This means compensating for the additional costs incurred or losses suffered directly as a result of the regulatory change, thereby neutralizing its financial impact and upholding the original economic equilibrium of the contract.
Question
What is the "expert body doctrine" and how does it influence a court's approach when reviewing decisions made by specialized regulatory tribunals?
Solution
The "expert body doctrine" is a principle of judicial review where constitutional courts exercise restraint and deference when examining decisions of specialized technical or regulatory bodies. Courts recognize that bodies like electricity regulators possess specialized expertise and experience in their respective fields. Therefore, a court will not ordinarily substitute its own views for that of the expert body. Interference is warranted only on limited grounds, such as if the decision is ex facie arbitrary and illegal, fails to consider mandatory statutory provisions, or is based on extraneous considerations. This doctrine ensures that complex technical and policy matters are primarily decided by the designated experts.
bottom of page